Picture it.

You’re Captain of a US Navy Destroyer.
You’ve got a handful of other destroyers to help you.
You’re protecting several dozen ships loaded with munitions, fuel, and troops.
You’re beyond the help of shore-based aircraft.
You’re on your own.
And you, your fellow escorts, and the ships you’re protecting are being hunted.
And no matter what call you make, it can be the wrong one.
Let me start by saying that Tom Hanks is one of my favorite actors. The guy could do a car commercial and I’d think it’s awesome. In this Movie, Hanks plays Cmdr. Ernie Krause in command of the Fletcher class destroyer, U.S.S. Keeling.
And what I described above is exactly the situation he finds himself in.
The surpising part is I didn’t even know this movie was out there till I caught a small bit of on YouTube. That’s when I found it had been out since 2020. It’s based on C.S. Forester’s book, The Good Shepherd. They made the movie, and thanks to COVID, it never made it into the theaters.
Instead, it went to streaming which explains why I never heard of it.
I don’t want to give away too much of the story. But the actions sequences are intense and nail biting. The CGIs are great and reflect well the frightening nature of the Battle of the Atlantic. In one scene, the German U-boats are surfaced, and chasing after the convoy. The term for such a massed formation was a “Wolfpack”. You get the sense of wolves chasing helpless sheep beautifully.
In one frightening scene, a crippled U-boat surfaces and cozies right up against another destroyer. It sits there firing into the ship it’s near. The ship it’s close to can’t depress its gun enough to defend itself. And anyone coming to assist can’t fire either for fear of hitting the ship the U-Boat is near. A very unnerving place to be and the tension of the moment is palpable.
Hanks is in top form here. I haven’t read the book, but he shows Krause as a man of prayer. He’s praying going into the area haunted by the U-Boats. He prays during the battles. He gives thanks when they get out the other side. He shows a man who’s doing the very best he can. And he knows that there are instances where there is no right call.
And it does a very good job of showing logistics and things going wrong in a tactical situation. The fuel supply of the destroyers is a constant concern for Hanks. They have a limited supply of weapons. Towards the end, they’re low on depth charges, and the enemy still looks very strong.
Equipment malfunctions from ice the the wipers won’t clear to radar giving problems.
Speaking of the enemy, the German U-Boat commanders. They come up on the radio and taunt Hanks in a voice that would make Dracula cringe. This is perhaps some of the best of the man he portrays. Krause hears them. And if they bother him, he doesn’t show it.
Hanks turns in a performance that easily rivals what’s been done in the past. He reflects the loneliness and exhaustion of command well.
I got to get the book and read it.
All pictures from the movie

If you’re a Veteran in crisis or concerned about one, connect with our caring, qualified Veterans Crisis Line responders for confidential help. Many of them are Veterans themselves. This service is private, free, and available 24/7.
Here’s how you can connect with a Veterans Crisis Line responder, anytime day or night:
- Call 988 and select 1.
- Text 838255.
- Start a confidential chat.
- If you have hearing loss, call TTY: 800-799-4889.
If you’re not a veteran or wish you can also take these actions:
- Call 911.
- Go to the nearest emergency room.
- Go directly to your nearest VA medical center. It doesn’t matter what your discharge status is or if you’re enrolled in VA health care. if not a veteran, go to your nearest hospital.
Find your nearest VA medical center
Discover more from William R. Ablan, Police Mysteries
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

This was fascinating, but I was disappointed to learn it’s not based on a true story, but was inspired by historical events and Forster’s novel.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I read that book in the 1980s, it was in my library. Loved it and want to read it again. Hope I can catch the movie but don’t have a streaming service. Fine review.
LikeLike
Thanks for the review. I’ll have to watch it.
LikeLike
Thanks for bringing this to my attention, Rich. I’ll find out where I can stream it from.
LikeLike
Hi all.
Rich is right. It’s a pretty good movie.
My wife and I saw the trailer for it while we were stationed in Jamaica and she hunted down her old Apple account from work so we could watch it. (We’re glad she did too, Apple+ has a pile of good shows and movies just like this one.)
BUT- since it’s an Apple+ movie, you can only stream it with an Apple account. Although it IS (misleadingly!) available on Amazon Prime, but only if you access Apple through Prime, as of the last time I checked.
Since Rich already mentioned it’s good and why, I’ll skip that and jump right to why it was of personal interest to me.
My grandfather served on a Fletcher in the Pacific. He was assigned to DD-586, the USS Newcomb.
(I don’t know if I can post links in here… I will try at the end. If not, maybe I could toss them at Rich to put in here, if anyone’s interested.)
The REALLY short version:
The Newcomb was involved in assorted roles for many well-known battles (Saipan, Tinian, Palau, the Philippines (including Leyte Gulf and Surigao Strait), Iwo Jima, and Okinawa) until she was attacked by a few kamikazes.
Yes, a few.
The report says “at least 7, but the “official” total is 5 that actually struck the ship, with the 5th one skipping off her deck into another Fletcher from DesRon 54 (USS Leutze, DD-481) that had come alongside to render aid by evacuating wounded and fighting fires.
The war ended before either ship was repaired and both were decommissioned then scrapped in 1947.
Here are some links if you’re interested. Using your search engine of choice, you can find others and vid clips on YouTube or Reddit.
Links:Fletchers in general:https://destroyerhistory.org/fletcherclass/A more detailed link, specific to USS Newcomb:https://destroyerhistory.org/fletcherclass/ussnewcomb/A USNI article by one of Newcomb’s Captains:https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/1948/june/uss-newcomb-dd-586-victim-kamikazesThe repair orders including pictures of damage:http://www.researcheratlarge.com/Ships/DD586/DD586ForwardRepair.htmlA brief video of shore support operations at Okinawa 5 days before she was knocked-out of the war:https://www.reddit.com/r/CombatFootage/comments/18t1lkk/fletcherclass_destroyer_uss_newcomb_on_shore/
LikeLike
There’s on heck of story. Wow. thanks for the share.
LikeLike
Thanks, man.
I’ve been hunting for more of the Newcomb for awhile now, just saw her in one of the WW2 In Color documentaries.
And if you want to remove my initial post so I can fix those links, just let me know when to resend it, Rich.
LikeLike